Row at Home Like a Pro: The Best Rowers
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Some links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.
If you want a rower you’ll actually use, focus on three things: resistance type (air, magnetic, or water) for feel and noise, footprint/storage for your space, and reliability/support (warranty, parts, app ecosystem).
How I researched
I compared late-2025 expert roundups, deep-dive tests, and maker manuals, prioritized stroke feel, noise (apartment friendliness), fit/ergonomics (seat height, rail length), and long-term reliability (warranties, parts). I verified dimensions, monitor/app compatibility, and noted availability/EOL changes. I weighed performance consistency, maintenance needs, and ownership costs.
Top picks
Concept2 RowErg — Best for most people & training
The benchmark for durability, accurate metrics, and resale value.
Why it wins: Proven air resistance feel, bulletproof build, PM5 data you can trust.
No products found.
Pros
-
PM5 monitor is accurate and reliable
-
Broad app support (ErgData, others)
-
Splits into two pieces for storage
-
2-/5-year transferable warranty
Cons
-
Fan noise rises with intensity—fine for garages
-
No built-in classes; use apps
-
Air rower footprint is long
Social proof
Widely used in gyms and competitions; see reviews on Amazon.
Trade-offs / Who should skip
Apartment dwellers sensitive to fan noise may prefer magnetic or water models.
Scores: Performance 5/5 · Noise 3/5 · Ease of Use 4/5 · Value 5/5
Key facts: 96″ L x 24″ W; standard legs 14″ seat height (20″ tall-leg option); PM5 with Bluetooth/ANT+; free ErgData app; 2-year parts / 5-year frame warranty.
Hydrow Wave — Best for live classes in a compact footprint
Immersive classes with electromagnetic resistance in a smaller, lighter frame.
Why it wins: Best “connected-fitness” experience without the bulk of the larger Hydrow.
- UPRIGHT AND SECURE STORAGE: Easily store your Hydrow Wave rowing machine with the Vertical Anchor. This kit allows you to stabalize your rower vertically and store it in order to maximize living space.
- WALL MOUNTED DESIGN: This accessory must be installed correctly into your wall, following the steps in the included installation guide. It should only be used with the Hydrow Wave as directed and is not a good solution for securing or hanging any other variety of exercise equipment.
- KIT INCLUDES: strap, plate, cover, wood studs, washers and drill bit. KIT REQUIRES: drill, stud finder, level, wrench, pencil, and measuring tape. (This anchor is not compatible with drywall with metal studs).
Pros
-
16″ HD touchscreen with rich classes
-
Quieter than air rowers
-
80″ x 19″ x 43″—easier to place
-
Upright stow kit available
Cons
-
Membership required for full experience
-
Couldn’t verify UL/ETL of the adapter
-
Heavier than budget magnetics
Social proof
Strong professional and owner feedback; see reviews on Amazon.
Trade-offs / Who should skip
If you don’t want subscriptions, consider Concept2 or a basic magnetic rower.
Scores: Performance 4/5 · Content/App quality 5/5 · Ease of Use 4/5 · Value 4/5
Key facts: ~102 lb; electromagnetic resistance; typical warranty lists multi-year frame coverage—confirm current terms at checkout.
WaterRower Natural (S4) — Best for quiet, furniture-grade feel
A beautiful wood frame and soothing water “whoosh” that stores upright.
Why it wins: The most living-room-friendly aesthetics with a smooth, low-impact stroke.
- The Original Waterrower - Handcrafted and Built to Last: Designed in the mid '80s by Yale and US National Team Rower John Duke. WaterRower continues to combine stylish design, handcrafted workmanship, our unique WaterFlywheel resistance and ethically sourced materials create the world's finest rowing simulator
- Made in the USA - Hand-built in Rhode Island; all timber used in the manufacture of wooden WaterRower rowing machines is sourced from sustainably managed hardwood forests in the Appalachian Mountains. The ASH Rower is Made of Ash Wood with a Natural Color Finish
- Smooth - Water rowers use a water-filled flywheel to provide resistance as you row. The resistance is created by the paddle-like blades of the flywheel moving through the water, creating a smooth and natural resistance that closely resembles the feeling of rowing on water. Like water, the harder you fight, the more resistance you get
Pros
-
Quiet, realistic water feel
-
Stores upright in seconds
-
Solid hardwood, durable tank
-
Optional heart-rate add-ons
Cons
-
S4 monitor is basic vs. smart screens
-
Requires occasional water treatment
-
Heavier to move when tank is full
Trade-offs / Who should skip
If you need advanced metrics or classes, Hydrow or Concept2 fit better.
Scores: Performance 4/5 · Noise 4/5 · Ease of Use 3/5 · Value 4/5
Key facts: 82.25″ L x 22.25″ W x 20″ H; ~63.5 lb dry / ~100–103 lb with water; common warranty: 5 years frame / 3 years parts with registration.
XTERRA ERG600W — Best affordable water feel
A value-priced water rower with vertical storage and a simple console.
Why it wins: Brings the fluid stroke and sound of water well below premium prices.
- Water tank impellers — creates tranquil water-like sounds for a realistic rowing experience
- 7 workout programs included — keeps you engaged and motivated
- 6 resistance levels — adjustable by water volume in the tank
Pros
-
Real water resistance on a budget
-
Stores upright; transport wheels
-
5-yr frame / 2-yr parts warranty
-
Raised seat vs. many budget units
Cons
-
No Bluetooth (console is basic)
-
Couldn’t verify third-party app support
-
Some assembly required
Social proof
Well-regarded as a value pick; see reviews on Amazon.
Trade-offs / Who should skip
Metric-hungry users should consider Concept2; content seekers should go Hydrow.
Scores: Performance 3.5/5 · Noise 4/5 · Ease of Use 3.5/5 · Value 4/5
Key facts: 80.7″ x 22″ x 33″; maker lists 5-yr frame / 2-yr parts / 90-day labor; no Bluetooth.
Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5515 — Best sub-$300 magnetic
A quiet, no-frills magnetic rower that’s an easy entry point for cardio at home.
Why it wins: Whisper-quiet resistance and simple operation at a low commitment.
- 【TOTAL BODY WORKOUT】Full-body Workout with Extended Slide Rails. Engage & strengthen legs, glutes, core, back, arms & shoulders. Rowing activates multiple muscles, promoting balanced development & strength. Unlock your potential.
- 【EXTENDED SLIDE RAIL】At 48 inches in slide rail length, and 44 inches in inseam length, the SF-RW5515 can accommodate rowers up to 6 feet 8 inches tall.
- 【SUPREME COMFORT】Designed for effectiveness without compromising in comfort, its ergonomically crafted cushioned seat allows for extensive cardiovascular rowing workouts maximizing calories burned.
Pros
-
Quiet magnetic resistance
-
Simple, reliable mechanics
-
Compact footprint for small rooms
-
Easy to move and store
Cons
-
Basic LCD; no Bluetooth
-
Not ideal for very tall users
-
Build favors light-to-moderate use
Social proof
Popular budget bestseller; see reviews on Amazon.
Scores: Performance 3/5 · Noise 5/5 · Ease of Use 4/5 · Value 4.5/5
Key facts: Approx. 78″ x 19″ x 23″; straightforward setup and operation.
Quick compare
-
Hydrow Wave — Best for classes: compact, immersive training; ongoing membership.
-
WaterRower Natural — Best for quiet aesthetics: wood build & water feel; basic S4 monitor.
-
XTERRA ERG600W — Best affordable water rower: upright storage; no Bluetooth.
-
Sunny SF-RW5515 — Best sub-$300 magnetic: quiet and simple; limited metrics/fit for tall users.
Buying guide
1) Pick your resistance by space & sound
-
Air (Concept2): most “athletic” feel and precise pacing; louder whoosh—great for garages or daytime use.
-
Magnetic (Sunny): quietest for apartments; resistance is smooth but less “lively.”
-
Water (WaterRower/XTERRA): realistic stroke and pleasant sound; add a chlorine tablet periodically and plan for heavier moves.
2) Fit & ergonomics
Seat height matters if you have cranky knees (Concept2 offers 14″ or 20″). Long inseams may need longer rails (Concept2 specifies a 38″ inseam before an XL monorail). Check rail length and maximum user height before buying.
3) Metrics & classes
If structured data, heart rate, and broad app compatibility are key, the Concept2 PM5 plus ErgData is the most open setup. If you thrive on guided content and scenic rows, Hydrow’s platform is outstanding—just budget for the membership.
4) Warranty & support
Aim for at least 2 years on parts and 5 on frame for serious training use. WaterRower typically offers 5 years frame / 3 years parts with registration. Budget units often carry shorter coverage.
5) Safety & recalls
Before buying, quickly check for recent manufacturer recalls and service bulletins. If a model shows an active recall, skip it.
FAQs
Q: Air vs. magnetic vs. water—what’s quietest?
A: Magnetic is typically quietest (great for apartments). Water is a soft whoosh. Air is the loudest at higher efforts. Choose based on neighbors and workout times.
Q: Do I need a subscription?
A: No—Concept2 works great with its PM5 and free ErgData. Hydrow’s value is in its classes; you can “just row,” but most buyers use the membership.
Q: How much space do I need?
A: Concept2 is 96″ long and splits into two pieces for storage. Hydrow Wave is 80″ long and can stow upright with a kit. WaterRower stores vertically on its end. Measure your usable length plus a bit of clearance.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.